# At 15, Brazil's Access to Information Law answers almost everything, but the numbers mislead

In Brazil's federal government, 99.57% of almost 1.7 million requests made under the LAI were answered, in 14.5 days on average. For Karina Furtado Rodrigues and Temístocles Murilo de Oliveira Jr., these indicators are essential, but read without context they tell the wrong story.

- Section: Politics
- Published: November 17, 2026
- Address: https://ceoone.com.br/en/article/at-15-brazils-access-to-information-law-answers-almost-everything-but-the-numbers-mislead
- Em português: https://ceoone.com.br/artigo/aos-15-anos-a-lei-de-acesso-a-informacao-responde-quase-tudo-mas-os-numeros-enganam.md

![Stage of the seminar on transparency and access to information held by the Office of the Comptroller General in Brasília, with a panel seated in armchairs under a large screen reading "A transparência é o caminho para um Brasil melhor", while photographers and the audience watch](https://pub-b80e49b2737940b3ab5d3f20d0578192.r2.dev/artigos/aos-15-anos-a-lei-de-acesso-a-informacao-responde-quase-tudo-mas-os-numeros-enganam-foto.webp)

Photo: Palácio do Planalto/Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)

## Key points

- Brazil's Access to Information Law turns 15 with 99.57% of requests to the federal government answered, in 14.5 days on average.
- For Karina Furtado Rodrigues and Temístocles Murilo de Oliveira Jr., denials, appeals and classified documents alone do not show whether an agency is efficient or opaque.
- Without context, they argue, good indicators can tell the wrong story about how the law works.

Brazil's Access to Information Law, known as the LAI, turns 15 on Wednesday (18). The federal Executive's numbers look like something to be proud of: up to October 2026, according to the LAI Panel, 99.57% of almost 1.7 million requests were answered, in 14.5 days on average. In an article published on Tuesday (17) in Folha de S.Paulo, two researchers who study public management warn that these indicators, on their own, can lead to the wrong conclusions.

Karina Furtado Rodrigues is a professor at FGV and at the Brazilian Army's Command and General Staff School, and heads the Laboratory of Governance, Management and Public Policy in National Defense. Temístocles Murilo de Oliveira Jr. is the internal affairs officer of the Ministry of Culture and a researcher at the same laboratory.

## Denials that need a diagnosis

Many requests are refused on the grounds that they would require "additional work" or that they are "unreasonable". For the authors, this is a symptom without a diagnosis. A denial may point to poor internal information management, where the agency cannot find and organize what it holds. But it may also reflect the complexity of the request and data spread across departments. The number alone does not say which it is.

## Appealing is not always a sign of failure

The appeal rate is another indicator usually read as a measure of inefficiency. The authors disagree: often, an appeal is a necessary step to clarify an imprecise request, where the citizen and the agency only agree on what was asked after a second round.

## Secrecy with rules can be transparency

The number of documents classified as confidential also calls for caution. An agency that classifies more is not necessarily more opaque. Formal classification brings deadlines, accountability and traceability: someone signs the decision, it has an end date and it can be challenged. Without it, the information may simply stay out of public reach, with no record at all.

## The average that hides the spread

Response time and quality are another point. In appeal decisions by the Office of the Comptroller General, the deadlines given to agencies to comply vary widely, mostly between 30 and 120 days. The longer ones are linked to the complexity of the request and the agency's capacity to meet it. That is why the average number of days can hide very different situations.

## Those who apply the law decide case by case

The authors draw attention to the nuances of implementation. Behind each answer there are civil servants interpreting rules and reconciling rights. The clearest example is the relationship between the LAI and Brazil's General Data Protection Law: not all personal data is automatically protected, and whoever answers the request must weigh, case by case, the privacy of the people in the information against the public interest in releasing it.

The challenge, they conclude, is not only to improve the indicators but to understand what happens behind them. "Good indicators are essential, but, without context, they can tell the wrong story about how the LAI works."

## Sources and editorial notes

- Based on the article "O que os índices não mostram sobre a Lei de Acesso à Informação" (What the indices do not show about the Access to Information Law), by Karina Furtado Rodrigues and Temístocles Murilo de Oliveira Jr., published in the Tendências/Debates section of Folha de S.Paulo on November 17, 2026.

CEO ONE · https://ceoone.com.br

