# When milk strains the budget, bones pay the price

In Paraisópolis, women recently diagnosed with osteoporosis say they barely consume calcium because milk and cheese are expensive. A UnB study shows Brazilians take in less than half the recommended amount, and those who went hungry as children are 38% more likely to develop the disease.

- Section: Longevity
- Published: November 16, 2026
- Address: https://ceoone.com.br/en/article/when-milk-strains-the-budget-bones-pay-the-price
- Em português: https://ceoone.com.br/artigo/quando-o-leite-pesa-no-bolso-os-ossos-pagam-a-conta.md

![Two wheels of aged cheese, one cut in half, on a pale stone in soft light](https://pub-b80e49b2737940b3ab5d3f20d0578192.r2.dev/artigos/quando-o-leite-pesa-no-bolso-os-ossos-pagam-a-conta-foto.webp)

Photo: Alexander Maasch/Wikimedia Commons (CC0)

## Key points

- In Paraisópolis, women recently diagnosed with osteoporosis say they barely consume calcium because milk and cheese are expensive.
- A UnB study of more than 34,000 Brazilians found that women aged 51 to 70 take in less than half of the recommended 1,000 mg of calcium a day.
- Those who went hungry as children are 38% more likely to develop the disease, and eating habits formed early are hard to correct in adult life.

One afternoon in October, five women met at the public health clinic in Paraisópolis, one of Brazil's largest favelas, in the south of São Paulo, to talk about the osteoporosis diagnosis three of them had just received and how the disease is treated. A few minutes into the conversation, the doctor who leads the group spotted something they all had in common: every one of them said she consumed little or no calcium.

The reason, they said, is money. "I didn't drink milk because it was expensive. Truth is, I never ate healthy things. Good food is something you can't afford," said Maria Aparecida Rodrigues, 61.

## Doing the calcium math

Gynecologist Helena Becker, of Hospital Israelita Albert Einstein, explained to the group how many glasses of milk it takes to reach the day's calcium: four 200 ml servings. "I can't afford to drink milk," Maria repeated.

The World Health Organization recommends 1,000 mg of calcium a day to maintain bone mass. That is the equivalent of four standard glasses of milk, or 800 ml, nearly a whole carton, which costs between R$ 4.50 and R$ 10. According to a 2022 survey by the Instituto Favela Diz, 37% of Paraisópolis residents reported earning between R$ 900 and R$ 1,800 a month.

## A silent disease

Osteoporosis weakens the bones over time and raises the risk of fractures. It shows no signs at first, and as it advances it can cause pain, loss of height and a stooped posture. It is linked to aging, but also to lifestyle and nutritional deficiencies.

Lack of access to healthy food is tied to higher rates of osteoporosis in old age. A national study published in 2022 in the Pan American Journal of Public Health traces the problem back to the start of life: among 9,400 Brazilians aged 50 or over, having gone hungry as a child raised the chance of developing the disease by 38%. Food deprivation and late diagnosis are more common among non-white people, those with less schooling, lower family income and those living on the urban fringes.

## Less than half of what is needed

Another study, by researchers at the University of Brasília in 2019 using data from the national Household Budget Survey, linked food insecurity to low intake of the nutrients that prevent and treat osteoporosis. Analyzing the daily calcium intake of more than 34,000 Brazilians, it found that women aged 51 to 70 averaged 366 mg to 387 mg a day, less than half of what they need. They are the most vulnerable to the disease because of menopause.

The study also looked at vitamin D, without which calcium is poorly absorbed: intake is inadequate for 98% to 99% of Brazilians over 50. And it showed how tight budgets push families to swap fresh, micronutrient-rich food, such as milk and fruit, for cheaper ultra-processed products.

Experts call this "hidden hunger": people may get enough calories, but live with a chronic shortage of essential minerals such as calcium, iron and magnesium.

## Where calcium is found

The main sources of calcium are milk and dairy products such as cheese and yogurt, along with dark leafy greens such as kale, broccoli and spinach. The mineral is also found in sardines eaten with the bones, sesame, almonds and fortified foods, such as some plant-based drinks.

![A bowl of yogurt with strawberries, blueberries and granola on a table in window light](https://pub-b80e49b2737940b3ab5d3f20d0578192.r2.dev/artigos/quando-o-leite-pesa-no-bolso-os-ossos-pagam-a-conta-iogurte.webp)

Yogurt, one of the sources of calcium that weigh on the budget. Photo: Peter Hershey/Wikimedia Commons (CC0)

An average slice of semi-cured cheese (45 g) has about 313 mg of calcium; a slice of mozzarella (20 g), 175 mg. A canned sardine with its bones (41.5 g) provides about 228 mg. A tablespoon of sesame seeds (15 g) offers about 123 mg, and a serving of sautéed kale (42 g), 74 mg. These are estimates and vary with the food, the brand and how it is prepared.

## A habit that runs deep

Retiree Lindaura Cardoso Dantas, 71, moved to Paraisópolis a month ago to live with her son. In the interior of Bahia, where she was born and lived, she ate "beans with manioc flour and meat", the food that gave her energy for farm work, which supported her six children. "It was always very hard to eat different things there, there wasn't much available and we earned little. What mattered was feeding the children."

The family's diet only changed in the early 2000s, she says. It was not enough to build a new habit: today Lindaura drinks "one or two little glasses" of milk a day.

For Helena Becker, income also weighs on treatment once the disease has set in. "The people of Paraisópolis have lived lives of work from an early age, with extreme demands on the body and little time for self-care. How am I going to tell someone living on welfare to eat cheese every day, when a kilo costs more than R$ 100? Or even milk, which is also expensive?"

And a diet damaged in childhood is hard to correct in adult life. "A child who ate more sugar tends to have a palate geared toward sweetness. That shapes their eating path from then on, because other foods won't be as appealing." The doctor also points to work routines as another obstacle to healthy eating and physical activity, another key factor against osteoporosis.

## Sources and editorial notes

- Based on reporting by Luis Eduardo de Sousa, "Insegurança alimentar e pouco cálcio expõem os mais vulneráveis à osteoporose", published in Folha de S.Paulo (Saúde) on November 16, 2026, as part of the Saúde Pública project, supported by Umane.

CEO ONE · https://ceoone.com.br

